Posted by
Helen Aavik on Thursday, September 17, 2009 12:17:12 PM
Representative Joe Wilson’s rude “You lie!” outburst during the Joint
Session of Congress last week and the series of events leading up to it
provide a watershed moment for an object lesson in respect and trust
within this nation. However, as evidenced by recent pronouncements of
the racist nature of the American people, the lesson has apparently
been neither taught nor learned. Thus, we begin:
Before this
current administration even started, back in September 2008 the nation
was informed that the only thing between us and economic Armageddon was
an $700 billion dollar purchase of toxic assets from our toppling
financial industry. This was, at the time, an unheard of sum, an
obscene sounding sum. What’s more it had to be passed immediately.
Maybe
it was an emergency but there was a legitimate suspicion that it was
flim-flam. There was grave concern that this money, this nation’s
treasure created and provided by its good and decent people, was going
to disappear into the gaping maws of the nameless and faceless for a
not good enough reason. As we now know, much of that concern was
completely justified.
Thereafter, the same economic desperation
tactic and transparent-less outcome occurred with the Stimulus bill at
$787 billion dollars without even having been read!. Speedily
following came the omnibus bill and the budget bill, again in the
hundreds of billions of dollars.
This nation’s people are
overwhelmingly well educated people. Of course, I don’t mean to imply
Ivy League educated like most of the crew in D.C. But after spending
more in 9 months than in all the nation’s 233 years of existence well,
even the non-Ivy League educated deduced, something was afoot.
Incidentally, that elite pedigree no longer inspires the presumed
respect, much less trust, it once did for many, many decades. A pity
that, but I digress.
There was a reason the tea party
idea resonated so forcefully through the nation, several trillion
reasons actually. Plus which, it sounded fun in a harmless college
prank kind of way. However, the administration, leading democrats and
the mainstream media were not amused and some were nearly apoplectic.
Reporting with palpable disdain, Susan Roesgen described the
“anti-government, anti-CNN, not for family viewing” horde of uncouth,
manufactured, crazed mobs. Anti-government? (What, like McVeigh? Really?) Anti-CNN? (I bet they are now!) “Not for family viewing”? ( Oh really?)
Soon
the centralized health care proposals were being trumpeted along with
the now sickeningly familiar need-for-speed deadline of August and at
only a tad over yet another trillion dollars. The nation understood
the seriousness, either this gets stopped now or never. More derision
(“astroturf”), mockery (“teabaggers”) and slander (“extremists”) were
heaped upon the good, decent law abiding Americans of this great nation
by leading democrats, the formerly-known-as-mainstream-media and the
administration.
Never have the American people been so
contemptuously disrespected or grossly condescended to by their own
representative government and free press for demanding, of all things,
fiscal restraint in the face of trillions in spending. Nor have
Americans ever been so isolated and publicly humiliated by the
governing party for questioning, much less resisting unlimited power
over the most intimate aspects of their lives. Incidentally, it is
precisely this process of isolation and humiliation which is clearly
described in Saul Alinky’s book, “Rules for Radicals”.
But where
trust really became damaged between the people and this administration
was when the White House requested that the American people inform upon
one another by submitting “fishy” emails or casual conversations
regarding health care proposals. The administration also announced to
the press that it had written to its supporters sending them out to
attend the town hall meetings, counseling their supporters to “punch
back twice as hard” against those who were opposed. Some punched twice
as hard, first. One even bit off some poor guy’s finger.
Unsurprisingly,
these tactics did not have the desired effect upon the American people
that the administration anticipated. Instead of being intimidated,
cowed or shamed into quietude the American people raised their voices
together, sang their national anthem and shouted, in unison, “U.S.A.”
The
administration’s tactics are repugnant and utterly foreign to the
American people and the nation’s proud history. They are unprecedented
on this nation’s shores. Indeed, these very tactics have been
undertaken by despots in other lands for whom power was, or currently
is, unlimited. History is littered with their infamous names.
What
has been happening in the nation is unrecognizable to a great many and
was initially unnerving to most. However, the administration’s blatant
attempt to intimidate the citizenry has instead steeled their nerves
and galvanized their spirits.
Which brings it all back around
to Joe Wilson. Despite a sincere apology for his rude outburst which
was accepted by President Obama, the democrats within the House have
sought to publicly, and for posterity, humiliate him by entering an
unprecedented rebuke upon the House record. Perhaps because a rebuke
within the House was not public enough of a humiliation for democrats,
Wilson has now been announced to the world as racist by no less than
former President Jimmy Carter, and a few admittedly even lesser
personages. Likewise, the Americans who adamantly and passionately
disagree with Obama’s policies are also racists, proclaimed Carter.
The
administration has stated that President Obama does not believe the
opposition to his proposals is motivated by racism but he has not
disavowed it. Meanwhile the Snidley McSnides of the
ever-more-obsequious-media keep prattling on that its all racism.
It
isn’t just that this race-baiting is insulting, though it is. Nor is
it just that its so absurd. Mostly, it is such a profane act of
bullying one cannot countenance even a pretense of respect for those
who peddle it.
The lesson has been known since antiquity:
Governance through bullying, intimidation and humiliation never effect
respect or trust. Those tactics might effect fear in some places but
not in this nation. Bullying, intimidation and humiliation are tactics
which are utterly ineffective with Americans, including the youth.
Those tactics when attempted here result in what today’s youth would
deem “epic fail”